Prediction record

75% outcomesociety

The winter of 2022-2023 will be harsh in Europe.

A scored record for Peter Zeihan, made on .

VideoPrimary sourcesocietyenergy

Scored record

75% outcomesociety

the winter is going to probably be pretty harsh

The winter of 2022-2023 will be harsh in Europe.

Made on
2022-08-02
Outcome
75% outcome
Importance
4 / 5
Contribution
+3.98

Criterion

Resolution status
resolved
Resolved on
2023-03-31

The 2022-2023 European winter produces severe energy/economic hardship (shortages, rationing, or major price-driven distress).

Two-sided outcome. The criterion is disjunctive ('shortages, rationing, OR major price-driven distress'). The shortages/rationing leg clearly did NOT occur (mild weather + LNG buildout averted blackouts/rationing; storage stayed high). The price-driven-distress / economic-hardship leg clearly DID occur (>EUR 1T extra energy cost, prices ~265% above year-earlier, mass energy poverty, industrial curtailment, recession risk). Because the written criterion is satisfied by either branch, status is resolved; the quantify/score stage should weigh how literally to read 'harsh' (severe distress yes; physical shortage/rationing no). resolved_on set to the deadline (2023-03-31) since the assessment is of the full winter season.

Sources

  • Electricity in Transition

    YouTube ·

    Source

Outcome evidence

  • Europe spent over EUR 1 trillion more on oil, gas and coal in 2022 than the prior year (more than doubling energy's share of GDP); benchmark gas prices, though off their Aug-2022 peak (EUR 339/MWh), remained ~265% higher YoY through the winter, forcing huge government subsidies and squeezing households and industry. The UK's National Energy Action projected households in energy poverty rising from 4.5M to 8.5M; several gas-intensive industrial plants curtailed output and multiple European economies were expected to slip into recession over the winter. This satisfies the criterion's 'major price-driven distress / severe economic hardship' branch.

    Evidence

  • COUNTERVAILING (shortages/rationing branch NOT triggered): A US Federal Reserve FEDS Note concluded 'Europe weathered the past winter reasonably well, and the energy-related economic costs appear to have been more muted than initially feared.' An unusually mild winter (accounting for ~half the demand drop) plus rapid LNG import substitution (net non-Russian imports +44 bcm in 2022 H2, offsetting a 39 bcm Russian decline) meant Europe avoided the gas shortages, mandatory rationing and blackouts widely feared; storage ended the winter ~40% above the seasonal average. So the 'shortages/rationing' sub-condition did not occur even though the 'price-driven distress' sub-condition did.

    Evidence

Corrections

No public corrections.

Score contribution

+3.98
Confidence
80%
Outcome
75% outcome
Importance
4 / 5
Contribution
+3.98

This page displays the scored record as published; the website doesn't recompute or adjust the score.

Provenance

The winter of 2022-2023 will be harsh in Europe.
Methodology version
v1.0.0
Last computed
July 4, 2026
Made on
2022-08-02

How this profile was built

  1. Scored by independent judges

  2. Predictions gathered and sourced

  3. Independently verified against sources

Every public score traces back to sourced prediction records.

Avow is an independent project. The pundits scored here are not affiliated with Avow and do not endorse it. Names and likenesses are used for identification and commentary.

Evidence firstMethodology