Prediction record

Missenergy

Within a few weeks of March 23, 2022, ~4 million b/d of Russian crude leaving the market will produce the single largest oil-market disruption in human history.

A scored record for Peter Zeihan, made on .

VideoPrimary sourceenergymarkets

Scored record

Missenergy

it'll be the single largest disruption to oil markets in human history

Within a few weeks of March 23, 2022, ~4 million b/d of Russian crude leaving the market will produce the single largest oil-market disruption in human history.

Made on
2022-03-23
Outcome
Miss
Importance
5 / 5
Contribution
-2.22

Criterion

Resolution status
resolved
Resolved on
2022-06-23

By approximately mid-2022, roughly 4 million b/d of Russian crude is removed from the market, constituting the largest single supply disruption in recorded oil-market history.

Criterion: by ~mid-2022, roughly 4 mb/d of Russian crude removed from the market AND constituting the largest single supply disruption in recorded oil-market history. Both prongs fail on the evidence: net removal was on the order of ~0.7-1 mb/d (with ~2.2 mb/d gross off Western markets, ~2/3 rerouted to Asia), and that is smaller than prior disruptions (1979 ~5.6 mb/d). resolved_on = deadline 2022-06-23. No outcome value assigned.

Sources

  • Russian Refineries' Reduced Runs

    YouTube ·

    Source

Outcome evidence

  • Russian crude was NOT removed from the market at ~4 mb/d by mid-2022; exports largely held up and were rerouted rather than lost. Russian oil exports were ~7.4 mb/d in July 2022, vs ~8 mb/d at the start of 2022 and the 2021 average of ~7.5 mb/d. IEA reported crude and product flows to the US, UK, EU, Japan and Korea slumped by ~2.2 mb/d since the conflict began, but about two-thirds of that was REROUTED to other markets (notably India and China), not removed from the market.

    Evidence

  • Russian production dipped ~9% in April 2022 (~1 mb/d) but recovered; EIA reported Russian liquid-fuels output averaging ~10.8 million b/d since March 2022, far from a ~4 mb/d removal. Exports rebounded as Russia diverted barrels to India (record ~975,000 bpd by July 2022) and China.

    Evidence

  • Even on a gross-redirection basis, the volume off Western markets (~2.2 mb/d) was below the largest historical single disruptions: the 1978-79 Iranian Revolution peaked at ~5.6 mb/d lost (IEA) / crude output down ~4.8 mb/d, the 1973-74 Arab embargo ~4.5 mb/d, and the 1991 Gulf War ~4.3 mb/d. Spring-2022 Russian supply loss did not constitute the single largest oil-market disruption in recorded history.

    Evidence

Corrections

No public corrections.

Score contribution

-2.22
Confidence
85%
Outcome
Miss
Importance
5 / 5
Contribution
-2.22

This page displays the scored record as published; the website doesn't recompute or adjust the score.

Provenance

Within a few weeks of March 23, 2022, ~4 million b/d of Rus…
Methodology version
v1.0.0
Last computed
July 4, 2026
Made on
2022-03-23

How this profile was built

  1. Scored by independent judges

  2. Predictions gathered and sourced

  3. Independently verified against sources

Every public score traces back to sourced prediction records.

Avow is an independent project. The pundits scored here are not affiliated with Avow and do not endorse it. Names and likenesses are used for identification and commentary.

Evidence firstMethodology